Part One: The Diagnosis

Chapter 1

The Word Is Not Inflated

"Trauma is not what happens to you. Trauma is what happens inside you as a result of what happens to you." — Gabor Maté

Reading Time 55 minutes
Core Themes Neurobiology, Discharge, Civilisation, Epidemiology
Key Insight Trauma is incomplete discharge, not the event itself
Related Ch. 2, Ch. 3, Interlude

Core Thesis Established: Trauma is not the event: trauma is incomplete biological discharge. The evidence presented below substantiates this foundational claim with neurobiological research, animal ethology, clinical documentation, historical analysis, and epidemiological data suitable for academic citation.

Neurobiological Foundations Establish Trauma as a Body-Based Phenomenon

The convergence of research from Peter Levine, Stephen Porges, and Bessel van der Kolk provides the scientific architecture for understanding trauma as incomplete discharge rather than psychological memory.

Peter Levine's Somatic Experiencing Framework

Levine's foundational insight, developed over 45 years and published in Waking the Tiger (1997) and peer-reviewed journals, is that "Trauma is in the nervous system and body, and not in the event." An event traumatic to one person may not traumatize another based on their capacity to complete and discharge the survival response.

The mechanism Levine identified: When fight and flight are not options, organisms enter freeze, a time-limited survival response designed to run its course. The massive energy mobilized for fight/flight should discharge through spontaneous gentle inner shaking and trembling. If the immobility phase doesn't complete, that charge stays trapped. From the body's perspective, the person remains under threat.

A 2015 peer-reviewed paper in Frontiers in Psychology (Payne, Levine & Crane-Godreau) formalized this: "Post-traumatic stress symptoms originate from a permanent overreaction of the innate stress system due to the overwhelming character of the traumatic event. In the traumatic situation, people are unable to complete the initiated psychological and physiological defensive reaction. This leads to a persistent somatic and emotional dysregulation of the nervous system."

Key mechanistic finding: Ernst Gellhorn's research demonstrated that proprioceptive feedback from intense muscular activity triggers reciprocal parasympathetic activation. Without this feedback (when the defensive response is thwarted) the autonomic nervous system fails to reset. Laboratory evidence supports this: rats allowed to fight after stress-inducing experiences recover much faster than those kept separate and unable to complete their defensive response (Weinberg et al., 1980).

Stephen Porges' Polyvagal Theory

Porges' theory (1994, updated 2025 in Clinical Neuropsychiatry) provides the neuroanatomical framework explaining why trauma cannot be resolved through cognition alone. The autonomic nervous system operates through a phylogenetic hierarchy:

Ventral vagal complex (newest, mammals only): Supports social engagement, calm states, connection: the "window of tolerance" where cognitive processing functions. Sympathetic nervous system: Fight/flight mobilization. Dorsal vagal complex (oldest, reptilian): Immobilization, shutdown, collapse, dissociation.

When threat is detected through neuroception (subconscious neural threat detection that operates without conscious awareness) the system moves down this hierarchy automatically. Trauma responses are not voluntary choices; they're reflexive, hard-wired responses operating below cortical control.

The clinical implication: talking cannot reach systems that never involve language. As Porges stated: "The issue is really not the horrendous experience of the trauma, but trying to make sense of the physiological response that that traumatic event triggered."

Van der Kolk's Brain Imaging Evidence

Van der Kolk's neuroimaging research at Harvard (Rauch, van der Kolk et al., 1994) provided visual proof that trauma fundamentally alters brain function:

Amygdala hyperactivation: During traumatic flashbacks, the amygdala (the brain's alarm system) reacts with alarm even years after the original event, triggering cascades of stress hormones despite no current threat. Broca's area deactivation: The speech center goes offline during flashback activation. Van der Kolk termed this "speechless terror": the person is physiologically prevented from translating traumatic experience into language. Hippocampus dysfunction: Reduced hippocampal volume in trauma survivors impairs the ability to contextualize memories in time. Traumatic memories remain "timeless," not stamped with time and space, not integrated into autobiographical narrative.

Van der Kolk's summary in The Body Keeps the Score (2014): "Trauma is 'encoded in the viscera'... trauma literally reshapes both body and brain, compromising sufferers' capacities for pleasure, engagement, self-control, and trust."

The Difference Between Stress and Trauma

Levine's definition provides the critical distinction: "Stress is the inability of the complex dynamical system of the ANS to recover to normal functionality."

Stress Trauma
System returns to baseline System remains dysregulated
Response completes Response is interrupted/incomplete
Memory integrates normally Memory fragments, remains "present"
Temporary autonomic shifts Chronic autonomic dysfunction

The canonical animal model for PTSD requires threat plus restraint; neither alone produces trauma symptoms. The defensive escape response must be prevented; only then do lasting symptoms develop (Philbert et al., 2011).

Animals Demonstrate the Discharge Mechanism Humans Suppress

The Evidence for Neurogenic Tremoring

Peter Levine's central observation (that wild animals face constant predation threat yet don't develop chronic trauma) led to the discharge hypothesis. Documentation exists across species:

The impala/gazelle example: National Geographic footage shows an impala in tonic immobility after cheetah capture. When the cheetah becomes distracted, the impala undergoes visible shuddering for approximately one minute, followed by deep breathing movements, then escapes. The observation is genuine: animals do shake after tonic immobility. The proposed mechanism includes autonomic nervous system resetting, metabolic recovery after freeze response, and muscle unlocking from immobility.

Polar bears: The widely-cited video of a tranquilized polar bear shows intense body trembling, leg thrashing, biting motions, and gasping upon awakening, interpreted as completing the fight/flight response interrupted by chemical immobilization.

Dogs: American Kennel Club documentation: "When your dog shakes after hopping off an examination table at the veterinarian's office... he is trying to relieve tension." Dogs exhibit post-stress "shake-offs" after both positive and negative arousal.

Critical Scientific Assessment

The scientific literature reveals that while the discharge model is clinically compelling and evolutionarily logical, systematic ethological documentation remains limited. Most evidence comes from observational anecdotes, video documentation of specific incidents, and extrapolation from clinical observations to wild animals rather than controlled wildlife studies.

A 2019 study complicated the simple narrative by demonstrating that "predator-induced fear can cause PTSD-like changes in the brains and behaviour of wild animals," suggesting wild animals can develop trauma-like symptoms under certain conditions. This doesn't invalidate the discharge hypothesis but suggests the picture is more nuanced than animals always successfully discharging.

The evolutionary logic remains sound: prey animals face regular life-threatening situations; if they developed chronic stress symptoms, species survival would be compromised; natural selection would favour mechanisms for rapid recovery. The clinical efficacy of reactivating tremoring in humans (TRE research below) provides indirect support even where direct ethological documentation is limited.

Humans Retain Discharge Mechanisms but Are Trained to Suppress Them

TRE (Tension and Trauma Releasing Exercises) Research

David Berceli, PhD developed TRE based on observations in war zones and disaster areas. While working in bomb shelters, he observed that children naturally tremored after stress while adults suppressed this response: the same biological mechanism, different socialization outcomes.

The mechanism: TRE uses exercises designed to fatigue specific muscle chains, particularly the psoas muscle (the deep hip flexor connecting spine to legs). When the psoas fatigues, it triggers the body's natural neurogenic tremor mechanism, a gentle, involuntary shaking classified as an "enhanced physiologic tremor." This downregulates fight-or-flight arousal and shifts the body toward parasympathetic activation.

Clinical evidence:

The limitation noted in literature: "TRE's exact mechanism of action has not yet been elucidated" (PMC, 2024). However, clinical outcomes support efficacy regardless of mechanistic uncertainty.

The Physiology of Crying as Discharge

William Frey II, PhD (Director of Dry Eye and Tear Research Center, St. Paul-Ramsey Medical Center) conducted pioneering research on tear biochemistry over 15 years.

Three types of tears exist: Basal tears (continuous lubrication), reflex tears (response to irritants, 98% water), and emotional/psychogenic tears, which are chemically distinct. Frey found emotional tears contain 21% more protein than reflex tears, including:

Frey's hypothesis: "The reason people feel better after crying is that they may be removing, in their tears, chemicals that build up during emotional stress. When people use the expression 'to cry it out,' we are suggesting that this may literally be true."

Autonomic mechanism: A 2019 study found crying onset associates with sympathetic activation, while crying resolution associates with parasympathetic activation; the calming parasympathetic effects last 2-3 minutes longer than the arousing sympathetic effects, creating a net discharge effect.

Somatic Therapies Documenting Spontaneous Discharge

Clinical observations across somatic modalities document spontaneous discharge phenomena during therapy sessions: shaking/trembling, heat sensations, involuntary movements, breathing changes, yawning, and crying.

Somatic Experiencing (SE): Peter Levine's approach uses titration (approaching trauma gradually), pendulation (oscillating between activation and calm), and completion of thwarted defensive responses. A 2017 RCT (Brom et al.) demonstrated Cohen's d = 0.94-1.26 for PTSD symptom reduction, large effect sizes maintained at 15-week follow-up.

Sensorimotor Psychotherapy: Pat Ogden, PhD developed this approach targeting the "somatic narrative," physical manifestations including breath patterns, muscle tension, posture, and movement impulses. Research shows significant improvements in body awareness, anxiety reduction, and soothing receptivity.

Cross-Cultural Evidence on Shaking Practices

Bradford Keeney, PhD documented shaking as one of humanity's oldest healing modalities in Shaking Medicine: The Healing Power of Ecstatic Movement (2007):

Keeney documents how shaking medicine was systematically suppressed by religious and governmental forces across cultures, leading to its decline. The natural tremoring response came to be seen as weakness rather than profound self-healing.

The Civilizing Process Systematically Eliminated Discharge Mechanisms

Norbert Elias and the Progressive Constraint of Bodily Expression

Elias's The Civilizing Process (1939), ranked the 7th most important sociological book of the 20th century by the International Sociological Association, documented through analysis of etiquette and education manuals from the 13th-18th centuries how Europeans developed "changing conceptions of shame and embarrassment with respect to, among other things, bodily propriety and violence."

Core findings:

Key mechanism: "By the nineteenth century... manners are inculcated no longer by way of adult to adult verbal discourse... Socialization shifts from slow and conscious changes by adults over centuries to swift and silent indoctrination of children in their earliest years."

Historical Practices That Facilitated Discharge, and Their Elimination

Medieval carnival (documented by Mikhail Bakhtin in Rabelais and His World, 1965): Carnival represented "temporary liberation from the prevailing truth and from the established order" through feasts "of becoming, change, and renewal." The "grotesque body" was celebrated, parts open to the world rather than the "closed body" of official culture. Carnival "lowered all that is abstract, spiritual, noble, and ideal to the material level." This tradition died out with the Protestant Reformation and Counter-Reformation.

Ecstatic religious practices: "All documented religions have some element of the ecstatic," including Dionysian cults, Haitian voodoo, Native American shamanism, Kabbalists, Sufi mystics, and the Charismatic movement. Robin Dunbar's research found that even relatively modest synchronized movements (standing to sing, kneeling to pray) produce measurable releases of endogenous opioids. Protestant reformers specifically targeted this; Eduard Schick wrote: "Der Protestantismus ist seinem Wesen nach der Ekstase abhold oder gar feindlich gesinnt" (Protestantism is by its nature averse or even hostile to ecstasy).

Communal mourning rituals: "Grief was expressed in an open and unrestrained way that was cathartic and communally shared, very much in contrast with the modern emphasis on controlling one's emotions and keeping grief private" (The Conversation). Irish keening, death wails, "merry wakes," all systematically suppressed. "As Christianity spread through Eastern Europe, the church sought to impose its own rituals and norms around death and mourning... The communal acts of mourning, such as wailing, lamenting, and even the hiring of professional mourners, were seen as 'pagan.'"

Political suppression of grief: "In times of war, when the state needed the population to stay unified and strong, open displays of mourning were seen as weakening the collective resolve." Result: "Grief became something to be silenced, privatized, and institutionalized, something that no longer belonged to the collective or Earth but to the state and church."

Emotional Socialization: "Stop Crying" as Civilizational Instruction

Research on developmental consequences of suppression messages:

Gender-specific suppression: "Although usually associated with younger children, the cliché 'big boys don't cry' is an example of how a young boy may be denied a masculine identity because he has displayed emotion." Boys are "socialized into emotionally inarticulate young men, unable to express depression" (Cambridge Core). Research links masculinity discrepancy stress to body image disorders and mental health problems in men.

Epidemiological Evidence Confirms Population-Level Crisis

The 42% Statistic: Verified

The Walton Family Foundation & Murmuration "Looking Forward with Gen Z" study (June 2022), conducted by John Della Volpe (Director of Harvard Youth Poll), found:

"Gen Z (42%) is about twice as likely as Americans over 25 (23%) to battle depression and feelings of hopelessness."

Additional findings:

Corroborating data:

Rates Are Genuinely Rising, Not Just Detection

CDC NCHS Data Brief No. 527 (April 2025): Depression prevalence among adults ages 12+ rose from 8.2% in 2013-2014 to 13.1% in 2021-2023, a 60% increase over a decade.

Household Pulse Survey: Anxiety/depression symptoms tripled from 11% in 2019 to 34% in October 2023.

Hidaka 2012 analysis (Journal of Affective Disorders, peer-reviewed):

Critical finding (N=9.2 million across 3 surveys): Poor mental health days among young adults 18-25 rose from 3.55 to 6.02 days per month between 1993-2020. Nearly all increase occurred before COVID-19.

ACEs Research: Trauma Exposure Is Nearly Universal

The CDC-Kaiser Permanente ACE Study (1995-1997, Felitti & Anda, published Am J Prev Med 1998) examined 17,337 participants and found:

Dose-response relationships:

Van der Kolk's framing: "For every soldier who serves in a war zone abroad, there are ten children who are endangered in their own homes."

The Structural Causation Argument

When 34-42% of a population reports symptoms, individual pathology cannot explain the phenomenon. The APA/WHO framework identifies "causes of the causes," the upstream factors:

Key social determinants identified: Discrimination and social exclusion, adverse early life experiences, low educational attainment, poverty and income inequality, food insecurity, unemployment/job insecurity, poor housing, climate change, adverse built environment, poor healthcare access.

Critical data point: Depression prevalence of 22.1% among those below poverty level vs. 7.4% among those at 400%+ of federal poverty level. Clear dose-response across income levels.

Hidaka's "diseases of civilization" framework: "Modern populations are increasingly overfed, malnourished, sedentary, sunlight-deficient, sleep-deprived, and socially-isolated. These changes in lifestyle each contribute to poor physical health and affect the incidence and treatment of depression."

Cognitive Approaches Have Documented Limitations; Somatic Approaches Show Efficacy

Why Talk Therapy Cannot Resolve Somatic Encoding

Van der Kolk's core critique: "Trauma is stored not as a story, but as a sensory experience" and therefore cannot be resolved solely through verbal processing.

Neurobiological basis:

Treatment dropout evidence:

Meditation Can Increase Anxiety in Trauma Survivors

Systematic review (Farias et al., 2020, Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica): Total prevalence of meditation-related adverse events: 8.3%. Among those experiencing adverse effects: 33% reported anxiety, 27% depression, 17% reported trauma re-experiencing, 10% dissociation/depersonalization.

US population study (PMC): 32.3% reported challenging/distressing experiences from meditation; 10.4% had effects lasting ≥1 month; childhood adversity correlated with elevated risk.

2025 study (Van Dam et al., Clinical Psychological Science): Nearly 60% of meditators experienced some adverse effect; approximately one-third found them distressing.

David Treleaven's Trauma-Sensitive Mindfulness (2018) explains: Mindfulness meditation practiced without trauma awareness can exacerbate symptoms. Survivors instructed to pay sustained inner attention "can experience flashbacks, dissociation, and even retraumatization." The breath, a common meditation anchor, "is not always neutral for people struggling with trauma; our respiratory system connects to our sympathetic nervous system."

Evidence for Body-Based Approaches

Somatic Experiencing RCT (Brom et al., 2017): First randomized controlled study of 63 participants with PTSD showed Cohen's d = 0.94-1.26 for PTSD symptoms (large effect sizes), Cohen's d = 0.7-1.08 for depression. Effects maintained at 15-week follow-up.

Yoga meta-analysis (2024, 20 RCTs, Psychiatry Research): Self-report PTSD: SMD = -0.51 (significant improvement); depression: SMD = -0.39. No serious adverse events reported.

Van der Kolk's yoga RCT: Frequency of yoga practice predicted decreases in PTSD and depression severity; yoga was efficacious at eighteen-month follow-up.

EMDR: Over 1,166 research articles published through March 2021. Meta-analyses confirm comparable or superior efficacy to trauma-focused CBT with shorter treatment duration and lower dropout. Body scan phase specifically addresses residual physical sensations; bilateral stimulation inhibits the amygdala and reduces physiological arousal.

Key Claims Substantiated

1. "Trauma is incomplete discharge": Supported by Levine's Somatic Experiencing framework, Payne et al. 2015 Frontiers in Psychology paper, Gellhorn's proprioceptive feedback research, and clinical documentation of spontaneous discharge in therapy.

2. "Animals shake after threat": Documented through video evidence (impala, polar bear), observational reports across species, though systematic ethological research remains limited. Evolutionary logic is sound; clinical efficacy of reactivating human tremoring provides indirect support.

3. "Humans have the same discharge mechanisms but suppress them": TRE research demonstrates neurogenic tremoring can be reactivated; Frey's tear biochemistry research shows crying as chemical discharge; cross-cultural documentation of shaking practices confirms universality of the mechanism; developmental research documents suppression training in childhood.

4. "The suppression of discharge is civilizational": Elias's The Civilizing Process provides the theoretical framework; historical documentation shows systematic elimination of carnival, ecstatic religion, communal mourning; emotional socialization research documents intergenerational transmission of suppression.

5. "42% of Gen Z reports depression or anxiety": Verified: Walton Family Foundation/Murmuration 2022 study; corroborated by Harmony Healthcare IT (42% diagnosed), Gallup (47% anxious), CDC data.

6. "Talk therapy has limitations for trauma": Van der Kolk's neuroimaging research shows Broca's area deactivation; dropout rates 24-56% for exposure therapy; 60-70% of veterans still meet PTSD criteria post-cognitive treatment.

7. "Meditation sometimes increases anxiety": 8.3% adverse event rate (Farias et al. 2020); 17-33% trauma re-experiencing; Treleaven's trauma-sensitive mindfulness work documents mechanisms.

Primary Researchers and Key Works

Peter Levine, PhD: Waking the Tiger (1997); In an Unspoken Voice (2010); Payne, Levine & Crane-Godreau, "Somatic experiencing: using interoception and proprioception as core elements of trauma therapy," Frontiers in Psychology (2015)

Stephen Porges, PhD: The Polyvagal Theory (2011); "Polyvagal Theory: Current Status, Clinical Applications, and Future Directions," Clinical Neuropsychiatry (2025)

Bessel van der Kolk, MD: The Body Keeps the Score (2014); Rauch, van der Kolk et al. neuroimaging studies (1994)

Pat Ogden, PhD: Trauma and the Body: A Sensorimotor Approach to Psychotherapy (2006)

David Berceli, PhD: The Revolutionary Trauma Release Process (2008); "Effects of self-induced unclassified therapeutic tremors on quality of life," Global Advances in Health and Medicine (2014)

Gabor Maté, MD: The Myth of Normal (2022); work on trauma, addiction, and civilization

Robert Scaer, MD: The Body Bears the Burden (2001)

Norbert Elias: The Civilizing Process (1939/1969)

William Frey II, PhD: Tear biochemistry research (1985)

Vincent Felitti, MD & Robert Anda, MD: CDC-Kaiser ACE Study, American Journal of Preventive Medicine (1998)

David Treleaven: Trauma-Sensitive Mindfulness (2018)

Bradford Keeney, PhD: Shaking Medicine: The Healing Power of Ecstatic Movement (2007)

Conclusion: The Diagnosis Is Structural

The research supports a coherent diagnosis: trauma is incomplete discharge: survival energy mobilized but never released, defensive postures assumed but never relaxed. Humans possess the same neurogenic tremoring and discharge mechanisms as animals but have been systematically trained to suppress them through millennia of "civilizing" processes.

When 42% of a generation reports depression or anxiety, when 64% of adults report adverse childhood experiences, when poor mental health days have nearly doubled in young adults before the pandemic even began, we are not observing individual pathology. We are observing the accumulated consequences of civilizational suppression of biological discharge mechanisms.

The wound is not what happened. The wound is what couldn't complete. This is not metaphor; this is diagnosis, supported by neurobiology, ethology, clinical research, historical analysis, and epidemiological data. The path forward requires body-based resolution of body-based encoding.

← Previous Table of Contents Next → The Wound